Chandigarh court quashes Dubai divorce order under Sharia law, upholds Indian matrimonial laws

A Chandigarh court has ruled a divorce order under Sharia law of a Dubai court to be null and void, stating that marriages solemnized in India according to Indian laws cannot be dissolved by courts abroad in a manner that goes against Indian matrimonial laws. The ruling upholds the dominance of Indian marriage laws in interpreting marital conflicts among Indian nationals.

Court’s Ruling and Major Arguments

The court has held that the Dubai court decree of divorce violates Indian public policy and destroys the sanctity of marriage secured in Indian law. The case dealt with a resident of Chandigarh who had challenged his divorce, awarded on the basis of Sharia law, even though he was married within India under Hindu Marriage Act, 1955.

The husband had instituted a suit arguing that the Dubai court could not dissolve the marriage under Islamic Sharia law, which does not apply to Hindu marriages. The court also noted that the defendant wife did not show up to counter the evidence put forward by the plaintiff, supporting his case.

Supreme Court’s Precedent on Foreign Divorce Decrees

The Chandigarh court relied on a Supreme Court judgment that foreign courts cannot dissolve Indian marriages against Indian matrimonial laws. The ruling makes it clear that foreign divorce decrees have to be consistent with Indian public policy and legal systems.

Impact on Alimony and Child Custody

The court also discussed the matter of permanent alimony awarded in the foreign divorce petition, which was claimed to contravene the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956. The judgment provides a guarantee that legal provisions relating to minor children are in adherence to Indian law.

ADVERTISEMENT

This ruling has far-reaching consequences for Indian couples living overseas. It emphasizes that marriages performed in India have to be terminated according to Indian matrimonial laws, regardless of where they live. The ruling makes a solid legal precedent for subsequent cases relating to foreign divorce orders and safeguards the rights of Indian citizens against capricious foreign judgments.

The Chandigarh court judgment upholds the legal sanctity of Indian marriages, ensuring they are covered by domestic laws and not foreign jurisdictions. This judgment is a landmark ruling, protecting Indian matrimonial rights and avoiding abuse of foreign laws in divorce matters.